COMMENTARY on the Yates Report Excerpts for Albany County
|The poor laws of New York State were a shambles by the 1820s. They had
been based on the English poor laws. But they fundamentally assumed that
the populace was not generally mobile -- that people would live in the
communities in which they were born -- or that if they moved, they would
quickly relocate in a community in which they would live for the rest of
their lives. Obviously, that is not the way the United States of America
was expanded and developed.
The industrial revolution made the situation much worse! For the first time in the generations-long history of their families, many were enticed to work for wages which involved temporary work. They followed the opportunity to work, and often found themselves far from any family or established long-term friendships when they became ill or injured.
The term "settlement" referred to a person's "legal residence". And according to the existing laws of settlement ... it was often impossible to determine to which community his care should be "chargeable" (or billed).
As a consequence, there was the constant temptation for communities to carry paupers to the edges of their jurisdiction and just "dump" them (and the responsibility for their care) in a distant location. They were often transported when sick or pregnant or infants ... and in the dead of winter ... and left in a totally unfamiliar location with no food or money or adequate clothing or shelter. (This was often done secretly under cover of darkness.)
The overseer of the poor of Albany (in this essay) really "told it like it was"! Attempts to deal with the situation through a legal process of removal were ludicrously inefficient and expensive and unfair to many parties. The cost of lawyers, travel expenses, etc. made it ridiculous. It actually often cost more to remove paupers than it did to support them.
It was the survey of poor relief practices such as these that the
Yates Report exposed and proved -- and it was as a result of these
situations that the system of county poorhouses was established.
|Return to Albany YATES REPORT Return to ALBANY page Return HOME|